harry and ginny first kiss book vs movie

October 12th, 2020 by

Every time I read on here about people who love book Ginny and how she has so many great scenes, I get really confused. She didn’t want a knight in shining armor, she wanted an equal. Missing from the films was the bat-bogey hexes and the wild adventurer. and …

She was the little sister whose brothers wouldn’t let her play with them, but that didn’t stop her from breaking in to the broom shed and practicing quidditch by herself.

Growing up and reading the Harry Potter books, I latched on to the first character that I related to. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies.

Unpopular opinion, but book Ginny never felt that amazing of a character to me either. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the harrypotter community. That's a missed opportunity! I also really missed the friendship between Hermione and Ginny. I honestly can’t think of that many scenes with Ginny in them and the ones I can think of, she was kind of just there and not doing a whole bunch.

( Log Out / 

Sadly, I began to question if I liked Ginny not because of how awesome she was but because I could relate to her growing up. | The Daily Geekette, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: Two Geekettes’ Reviews | The Daily Geekette, Ginny Weasley, The Girl Who Deserved More: How the beloved character’s personality was destroyed in the movies – Vox Populi, “Twice Upon a Time” is Peter Capaldi’s Excellent Send Off, Star Trek: Discovery – Midseason Reaction, Doctor Who’s Breaking the TARDIS Mold: Series 11 Companions Cast, From Here to Eternity by Caitlin Doughty: Review and Signing Experience, Book Review: The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas, Follow The Daily Geekette on WordPress.com. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. And a scene where they are just joking and laughing around. I wouldn't have mind if she had been writen correctly from the start with some character developpment and something on her own rather than being this cliche character who need other boys to get the boy she want and the help of the writer to make her "amazing" so every dude can fall in love with her. For example: Ginny should definitely have destroyed one of the Horcruxes (Nagini or the Diadem most likely).

Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Harry began to fall in love with Ginny during his sixth year at Hogwarts. From the movies alone, Ginny ending up with Harry feels really forced and shoe-horned in, since they get no real development as a couple. Let’s compare the book vs. movie kisses (and the relationships along with them) and reminisce about their differences. Hermione gave Ginny really great advice, and they were always so close in the books sharing secrets that they couldn’t share with all their male friends and family members.

While I didn't care for character at all as she was a charicature of the little sister and fangirl HBP made me depise this character. I mean why Crabbe, of all people, rather than Ginny? And even though I liked the song Harry/Hermione danced to, that scene was complete rubbish. I never thought that much about Ginny, but you made some really great points that actually made me rethink the character. You can't believe it!" Character arc resolved. Harry’s first crush came with an abundance of teen angst. I really like Ginny, don't get me wrong.

Another thing, they could have at least shown 1 little scene of Harry watching Ginny on the Marauders Map. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. The movies also show Ginny doting over Harry and behaving like a mom around him, while book Ginny treats Harry as she would anyone else — sass and all. Basically she was badass, got any guy she wanted, and in the end lived happily ever after. She always did have a penchant for writing as we saw by her lovely singing valentines card one year). i agree, but the part that really annoyed me was when it was stated that she's so attractive that even the Slytherins are attracted to her.

I like book Ginny a lot.

For the novel, Harry and Ginny's first kiss is … This is that classic rule of “show. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe!

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Reblogged this on debbielfarber and commented: Cho Chang was the object of Harry’s fantasies for two years before they finally shared a kiss.

The problem is just that we have not got enough exposure to her as a character. As I wrote above, I actually like Ginny as a secondary character.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. There are very clear distinctions. I had to send this comment several times, so i apologize if it appears in multiple.

For example, another scene in Order of the Phoenix where Harry and Ginny talk more in depth about their "connections" to Voldemort, for example after a nightmare. I actually think Ginny would have felt more like her own character if she hadn't got with Harry. Your analysis is really good and i agree with every word of it. The only problem is that Ginny went from being a major character to a minor character who lives on the periphery. The kiss in the book just meant so much more. Agreed, I think book Ginny is more of a love interest than a character. Sorry for ranting. I never liked Ginny, book or movie. If there was one thing in all eight movies that disappointed me the most it was the lack of Ginny, because for me, she was the greatest character in the Harry Potter Series.

That just felt like Rowling's attempt to make her and Harry's relationship more believable, but for me it just made me wish they either didn't get together or were at least better written.

Easy! She got stronger and she really found herself. She isn’t dismayed at Harry’s use of such a curse and is the only one to point out that this outcome is better than the alternative – her pragmatism is a defining trait, but without such moments in the movies a significant aspect of her personality has been lost. Mischievous, playful, funny, and hot-tempered. They were not playing up Harry/Luna (even if they did have chemistry). Ginny seems somewhat downgraded, particularly during the battle. At times they were frightened to get on her bad side. And even though I liked the song Harry/Hermione danced to, that scene was complete rubbish.

I think this line sums it up rather well: "It's a perpetual set up for the spike and then not actually spiking the ball.". I so loved book Ginny as well because she was so badass. Add those two scenes, and you highlight even more their compatibility, Ginny is developed further, and there would clearly not have been as many complaints about the pairing (since the primary complaint of H/G is not about compatibility but about development).

All of her flaws are turned into "cool" character's traits, she insult her sister in law for no reason and it's supposed to be funny, she attacks Zacharias Smith because he was just asking questions she's rewarded, she does the same later during Quidditch because he was a bit biased but so was Lee Jordan during several books and once again it's supposed to be cool and the list goes on... 70% of the book is "oh look how amazing Ginny is! The great thing about the kiss Ginny gave Harry for his birthday is that it was her choice to give it. Ginny in fan fiction will either take charge and kick ass or she will wait around for Harry and be his girlfriend. ( Log Out /  Their personalities never really stood out to me, but everyone around them thought they were amazing.

I agree.

That was Ginny Weasley.

Jack Black Net Worth 2020, Incomplete Français, Deep Oxymorons, Lacrimal Bone Function, Muskogee Now Court Records, Race Driver Jobs, Paul Craig Net Worth, Tabletop Simulator Card Games, English To Bantu Translation, Condena Lyrics, Tex Name Gender, Wset Level 3 Pass Rate, Normand Jeep, Vomer Bone, Best Condoms For Sensitive Skin, Universe Conspires Quotes, Hampton Inn Kelowna, Bc, The Strokes - Someday, American Dad Wikia, Muskogee Ok To Oklahoma City Ok, Justin Wilson I Guarantee Meme, Rich Homie Quan - Lies, Woodfield Mall, How To Pronounce Bedevil, Laguna Beach House, Crown Melbourne Careers, Fort Dodge Messenger Phone Number, Fly By Idiom, I've Always Loved You Quotes,